[ + Watch Now + ]

Mobile Security Industry News

TMCNet:  The Morning Call, Allentown, Pa., Watchdog column

[April 19, 2012]

The Morning Call, Allentown, Pa., Watchdog column

Apr 19, 2012 (The Morning Call - McClatchy-Tribune Information Services via COMTEX) -- Starting today, current and former Verizon customers can apply for a refund of unauthorized charges you unknowingly paid because they were "crammed" onto your phone bill.


Even better, you shouldn't have to deal with future cramming charges because Verizon and AT&T are taking a major step to prevent them.

Cramming occurs when your phone bill includes charges you didn't authorize from companies other than your phone company. They can range from phone-related services such as voicemail to nearly anything else, such as diet plans.

How the charges get on your phone bill is a complicated story, but suffice it to say that it's legal and is all about money.

Cramming gets its name because the charges are crammed among the many line items on your phone bill and may not be easily noticed. The Federal Communications Commission estimates 15 million to 20 million people receive crammed charges on their home phone bills annually, and many aren't immediately aware of it.

Verizon's refunds stem from the tentative settlement of a class-action lawsuit filed in California. The lawsuit alleged Verizon knew or should have known it was including phony charges from other companies on its bills, but looked the other way because it was getting paid to pass along the charges.

Verizon denies it did anything wrong or that it has any liability for third-party charges.

The tentative settlement (it still needs final court approval) applies to land-line phone customers of Verizon between April 27, 2005, and Feb. 28. You can file a claim for reimbursement of third-party charges from certain companies if you did not authorize them and haven't already received refunds. If you are not sure whether your bills included crammed charges, Verizon will give you a summary.

You can seek a flat payment claim of $40, or, if the false charges that you paid exceeded $40, you can seek full reimbursement by documenting how much you paid.

Verizon said by the end of the year, it no longer will include charges from most outside companies on its bills because of the threat of cramming. There will be an exception for "strategic partners" such as DirecTV, which provides the television component of Verizon's service bundles.

AT&T also will stop most third-party billing for land-line accounts, in August. Spokeswoman Brandy Bell-Truskey said AT&T has reduced cramming complaints, but wanted to do everything it could to give customers confidence in their bills.

Verizon was studying third-party billing last year, and took into consideration the class-action lawsuit settlement and a cramming investigation by the U.S. Senate. The company concluded the third-party billing services "were too prone to abuse," Verizon spokesman Lee Gierczynski said.

Cramming victim Debbie Dellegrotti of Lower Macungie Township said she told Verizon that last year. She said Verizon should have verified third-party charges before placing them on bills.

"You should have some sort of way of doing the cross-reference with your customer to make sure that it's OK," she said.

Dellegrotti said she'd discovered her Verizon bill contained a $15.85 monthly charge for "voicemail services." She said she hadn't signed up for voicemail services and didn't need to because it was part of her Verizon phone plan.

She told me she didn't immediately notice the charges. When she did and asked about them, she said Verizon removed the charge from her current bill, but told her she'd have to get a refund of what she'd paid in previous months from the company that had charged her.

Dellegrotti said she contacted Voice Mail Services, of Montana, and it told her she had signed up online.

She asked for the information on the account and said the name, address and email address were not hers, nor was the Internet IP address from the computer she supposedly used to sign up.

"It was a different person, it was a different address, and yet it was on my phone number," Dellegrotti said.

She got a refund for only six of the 13 months she had paid the charge. After I asked Verizon about it, it gave her a courtesy credit of the remaining $127.

Cramming wasn't an issue decades ago when AT&T (known as "Ma Bell") had a monopoly over wireline phone service and billed customers for only the services it provided.

That changed when the federal government broke up that monopoly in the 1980s, according to the class-action lawsuit against Verizon.

The Bell break-up split the nation's phone network into units operated by local exchange carriers such as Verizon. Those carriers broadened billing to also bill and collect for services provided by other companies.

Over time, Verizon and other carriers made their billing and collection systems "available to a myriad of providers of varied products and services," such as automobile roadside service, diet companies and credit repair services, the lawsuit says.

Verizon is paid to provide that service, but doesn't verify the validity of the charges it is passing on to its customers, the lawsuit says. Rather, it shifts that responsibility to the company that is paying it for billing and collection. And all an outside company needs to slap its charges on a person's phone bill is the person's phone number.

The lawsuit alleged that is "a virtual invitation to fraud and abuse" because phone numbers are widely available, potentially allowing anyone to be signed up for a service without their knowledge.

More details about cramming and the Verizon settlement are on my blog at http://blogs.mcall.com/watchdog/.

The Watchdog is published Thursdays and Sundays. Contact me by email at watchdog@mcall.com, by phone at 610-841-2364 (ADOG), by fax at 610-820-6693, or by mail at The Morning Call, 101 N. Sixth St., Allentown, PA, 18101. Follow me on Twitter at mcwatchdog and on Facebook at Morning Call Watchdog.

Verizon cramming settlement Eligibility: Current and former Verizon land-line customers from April 27, 2005, to Feb. 28, 2012, who were billed third-party charges submitted to Verizon by Billing Concepts, Billing Services Group Clearing Solutions, BSG, USBI, ZPDI, ACI Billing Services, OAN, Enhanced Services Billing, ESBI, HBS Billing Services, Billing Concepts, The Billing Resource, Integretel, ILD Teleservices, Transaction Clearing, PaymentOne, Ebillit.

File a claim: 877-772-6219 or http://www.verizonthirdpartybillingsettlement.com Deadline: Nov. 15 ___ (c)2012 The Morning Call (Allentown, Pa.) Visit The Morning Call (Allentown, Pa.) at www.mcall.com Distributed by MCT Information Services

[ Back To Mobile Security Homepage's Homepage ]

Follow Us

  • Mobile Security - LinkedIn
  • Mobile Security - Youtube
  • Mobile Security - Facebook
  • Mobile Security - Twitter
  • Mobile Security - RSS Feed

Request a Demo

Weekly Demonstration: SAP Mobile Secure
Solution including SAP Afaria Cloud

Free 30-day Trial

Best MDM in the cloud. Best MDM
Analytics. Best MDM price.

Featured Whitepapers

What Is Your Mobile Content Policy? A Checklist for Content Risk Mitigation
We are living in a world that only 20 years ago was the realm of science fiction. Devices once just barely imaginable have become common consumer items, carried casually in pockets and purses, with constantly growing capabilities.

SAP Enterprise Mobility: Bringing a Cohesive Approach to a Complex Market
Mobility and consumerization are creating complexity in the enterprise, but embracing the change can lead to more productive mobile workers as well as better communications with employees, partners, customers, and consumers. The trends in the enterprise mobility landscape drive a need for technology solutions to emerge.

Featured Datasheets

Securing Enterprise Mobility for Greater Competitive Advantage
We are living in a world that only 20 years ago was the realm of science fiction. Devices once just barely imaginable have become common consumer items, carried casually in pockets and purses, with constantly growing capabilities.

Secure Mobile Content Management for the Enterprise
Every day employees move business files onto their mobile devices so they can work at home, on the road, or at client sites. The mobile workforce is a reality, as 80% of employees say they need to access work documents from outside the office.1 Instead of insecure, consumer-based tools, enterprises need a safe, reliable platform for managing content on mobile devices.

Featured Webinar

Mobile Security - Mobile Drives Field Service Productivity at Satellites Unlimited

Mobile Drives Field Service Productivity at Satellites Unlimited
Field service has never been more competitive or faster changing than it is today. Going mobile is a must to stay ahead of the competition, provide improved services, and keep up with ever-increasing customer expectations.

Featured Webcast

Mobile Security - End to End Mobility Requirements: IDC and SAP explore the 3rd Platform

End to End Mobility Requirements: IDC and SAP explore the 3rd Platform
A new IDC study states that we're in the midst of a shift that takes place once every 20 - 25 years - introducing a new technology platform that will inspire growth and innovation for enterprises of all sizes. IDC calls it the 3rd Platform - built on mobile devices and apps, cloud services, mobile broadband networks, "Big Data", analytics, and social technologies.

Featured On-Demand Webinar

Mobile Security - Analyst Webcast: Secure Content Management in a Mobile Age

Analyst Webcast: Secure Content Management in a Mobile Age
Securing and managing content is taking on new importance as organizations try to cope with the explosion of business-oriented file sharing services while at the same time taking advantage of the proliferation of "smart" mobile devices.

Featured Infographics

Featured Press Releases